Mister Miracle #2 (May-Jun., 1971)

The cover of Mister Miracle #2, with its plethora of blurbs, follows in the tradition of the second issues of Jack Kirby’s Fourth World titles which preceded it.  Even more than the covers of Forever People #2 and New Gods #2, however, this one’s not just wordy, it’s shouty.  To my contemporary, 63-year-old sensibilities, it’s too much, at least by half.

But back in March, 1971, my thirteen-year-old self seems to have seen things differently.  That’s my prevailing theory, anyway, when I consider the fact that, unlike virtually any other comics purchases I made in the general timeframe of fifty years ago, I can remember the particular circumstances of my acquiring Mister Miracle #2.  While I don’t recall actually picking the book up out of the spinner rack at the Forest Ave. Tote-Sum in Jackson, MS, or paying for it at the counter, I do have a specific recollection of gazing upon that gloriously over-the-top cover as I held the comic in the front seat of my mom’s car, our having stopped at the aforementioned convenience store (at my request, I’m certain) on the way home from school. 

Of course, Kirby’s striking image of the titular hero about to be perforated by three very sharp-looking blades probably played a part in arresting my attention, as well as all that breathless copy.  Still, I believe it was the primarily the outpouring of new concepts and characters — Follower, Aero-Discs, Overlord, Granny Goodness, X-Pit — most of which were presented in the form of short, barked questions, that ultimately made this cover so memorable.  Those questions may well have fused with those that I had already formulated after reading the series’ first issue — who was this mysterious young “super escape artist” named Scott Free? and what did his relatively mundane dust-ups with human gangsters have to do with the war between the space-gods of New Genesis and Apokolips? — that gave me a sense of “Electric Tension” (also promised by the cover), which would only be resolved by my getting home and tearing right into the story.

Kirby opens his tale on what appears to be a relatively quiet scene featuring Scott and his friend and assistant, Oberon — or maybe not so quiet, since we’re seeing it from the perspective of Overlord — who, though unknown to us readers as yet, may be safely deemed to be some sort of mechanized being, on the evidence of his ticker tape-like “dialogue” and the intersecting pieces of Kirbytech that form the panel borders, among other things.  But whoever or whatever Overlord is, they obviously have lethal intentions towards our friend Scott.

We never get any details about the “factory people” responsible for filling Scott’s order, but it’s a pretty good bet that the DC Universe has at least a few industrial outfits who can fabricate one-off pieces of eyebrow-raisingly high technology to order — and will do so without asking a lot of questions.  Somebody has to build all that gear for Batman, right?

It appears that we were correct in assuming Overlord to be some kind of mechanical, robotic construct.  And a really big one, at that — or, at least that’s the impression we’re likely to take away from the way the thing fills up this full-page splash panel.

With page 5, we’ve finally arrived at the title and creator credits for this issue’s adventure.  As usual, it’s an all-Kirby production, with the exception of Vince Colletta on inks.

It’s not entirely clear what’s just happened — it looks like Overlord has fired a focused beam of some sort of energy blast right at Scott and his “Follower” (through a window, I guess?).  But, as will be confirmed via dialogue a little further on, the “volatile explosive” seen on page 3 (from the “N” on the can, I think it’s safe to assume it was nitroglycerine) has gone off as well.

In any event, the fire quickly spreads.  Oberon goes to work with a fire extinguisher, but  as the smoke rises, he quickly loses sight of the still straitjacketed Scott.  But no worries — when he finally reaches his friend, he find the young man uninjured, as well as free of his restraints:

We first saw Scott’s Mother Box in Mister Miracle #1, but it wasn’t named then — and, as I explained in my post about that issue back in January, my younger self wasn’t sharp enough at the time to have connected this device’s distinctive “pings” with those made by the Forever People’s bigger, redder model.  So, this sequence — which made that identification explicit — was probably when I realized that Scott almost certainly had to be from either New Genesis or Apokolips.

According to Wikipedia (and other online sources, as well), Kirby based the appearance of the most important female villain he created for his Fourth World mythos, Granny Goodness, on the late stand-up comic Phyllis Diller.  Kirby’s biographer (and former assistant) Mark Evanier doesn’t buy that idea, however; and I’m inclined to agree with him.

At this point, we still haven’t seen any character utter the word “Apokolips” — but, if you were taking bets on the location of Granny’s orphanage, which we now know to be Scott’s point of origin, well…

Page 10 gives us the issue’s cover scene… sort of.  Scott’s not in costume, and since it’s a practice session, its framing on the cover as a bona fide death trap seems just a little bit of a cheat.

This is the first mention in Mister Miracle of the Boom Tube, one of the defining concepts of the Fourth World.  Readers like me who were following all of Kirby’s DC titles had first seen the technology used in Forever People #1, in which the young heroes of that series traveled though it from New Genesis to Earth.  Since then, we’d learned that the Boom Tube was the primary mode of transportation to our world for the denizens of Apokolips, as well as for those of its sister god-planet.

Leaving the testing shed to go put on his costume, Scott doesn’t see the Follower return to “life” (how isn’t explained, but one might suppose that the automaton, though damaged in the blast, wasn’t damaged quite to the inoperable point our hero has assumed).  Nor does he bear witness as a small band of Granny Goodness’ “soldier boys”, believing the Follower to be Mister Miracle himself, burst into the shed, subdue both the Follower and Oberon with stun-gun blasts, and take them prisoner.

We first saw Scott’s “bag of tricks” the first time we saw him, on the opening splash page of Mister Miracle #1.  Later in that issue, our hero had described the bag and his contents as his “inheritance” — “Things left with a foundling by parties unknown!

Mister Miracle had flown in the previous issue (though off-panel), using “air jets” that were somehow attached to or built into his costume at the belly region.  Going forward, however, he’d rely on the much more visually appealing, and way cooler, Aero-Discs.

If any reader still has doubts at this point as to just where Granny Goodness and her pointed-helmet brigade — and, by implication, her “institution’s” one and only escapee, Scott Free — all hail from, the honored bust of “great Darkseid” should eliminate them handily.

Mister Miracle swoops down, retrieves the unconscious Oberon, and heads for the exits — but he’s immediately stymied by Granny, who orders her “pet”, Overlord, to open the X-Pit:

Why has Overlord provided cycle-control “studs” for the X-Pit cage inside the cage itself?  Beats me.  But, hey, they’re there, and so Mister Miracle keeps punching through.  The “electro-shock cycle” is followed by, well, mud:

Meanwhile, Granny enjoys the fawning solicitude of one of her soldier boys.  Kirby doesn’t highlight the idea, but we can’t help but be aware that, had he not managed somehow to escape, Scott would probably have turned out just like one of these obsequious little creeps:

On page 18, Mister Miracle said he couldn’t move enough to be able to press the stud.  Now, we’re told that he didn’t necessarily mean he couldn’t move his finger.  Um, OK.

We’ve discussed in previous posts how Mother Box, in all of her iterations, is more than a machine — she is, in some way Kirby never fully defines, alive.  In previous appearances, the writer-artist has emphasized her nurturing and loving — i.e., maternal — qualities.  (“She talks to us — protects us!” Vykin declared in Forever People #1, while in Mister Miracle #1, her pinging “voice” comforted Scott Free’s predecessor as Mister Miracle, Thaddeus Brown, as he lay dying.)  Earlier in this issue, however, we’ve seen that Mother Box has needs of her own, as we watched Scott nurse her back to health by feeding her his love and belief.  Now, Kirby goes even further, strongly suggesting that Mother Box herself can feel negative emotions as well as positive ones, as her retaliatory strike against Overlord is described by Scott as “vengeance”.  And since Overlord himself is more than a mere piece of technology — or is at least perceived as such by both Granny and Scott — Mother Box’s ending of him is to be taken not simply as one machine destroying another, but as one living being killing an equally living enemy.*  In Kirby’s world, the prospect of an artificial intelligence becoming truly alive clearly has a dark as well as a bright side.

Assuming that Kirby’s misdirection from page 4 has done its work (as it certainly did for the thirteen-year-old me, back in 1971), the revelation of the “true” Overlord should come as a real surprise.  It’s also likely to be at least slightly unsettling, as the being’s diminutive size plays into the earlier descriptions of Overlord as Granny’s “pet” — as being “too precious to be exposed to the world!”  Are we looking at the corpse of Granny’s dead infant child, in its tiny coffin?**

(Never really explained are the logistics of Overlord’s force-beam from earlier in the issue, which seemed to shoot directly from his forehead on page 4 to instantaneously arrive in the interior of Mister Miracle’s testing shack on page 5 — but that’s a minor point, in the end.)

Scott’s “parting words” to Granny Goodness are satisfying in their vehement defiance — though, as we’ll see in the issues to come, he wouldn’t be able to put this first of the two maternal presences in his life (the other one being Mother Box, of course) behind him quite so easily.

In some ways, Mister Miracle #2 can be considered the second half of the new hero’s “first issue”, as it appears to complete the set-up of the series’ premise that was left half-done at the conclusion of MM #1.  Now, with the revelation of Scott Free’s status as a refugee from Apokolips, we can see how his saga fits in with the other components of Kirby’s overall Fourth World epic.  Of course, we still don’t know Scott’s full story — and the revelation of his true significance, still nine months in the future, will cast everything we’ll have read about him up to that point in a whole new light.

Also still to come is the addition of one more character to the book’s regular cast, without whom the series’ set-up can’t truly be considered over and done.  That character, when she arrives, will bring a much-needed infusion of positive female energy (as contrasted to Granny Goodness’ negative incarnation of such) — not just to Mister Miracle, but to the Fourth World as a whole.

But, of course, that’s a topic for another post, some four months from now.  I hope to see you then.


*See Charles Hatfield, Hand of Fire: The Comics Art of Jack Kirby (University Press of Mississippi, 2012), p. 191, Kindle ed.

**Hatfield, p. 189.



  1. frodo628 · March 20, 2021

    I remember the cover of this issue, but not the story. Still, considering what a Kirby fan I was back in the day, I’m certain I owned this one. I have a question, however. As I understand it (and correct me if I’m wrong), Mr. Miracle is an identity that Scott took on Earth upon the death of Thaddeus Brown and wasn’t an identity Scott used on Apokolips at all. So, why did Granny call him “MIster Miracle” on pg 16? Unless she was aware of his career as a super escape artist and was mocking him for falling into her trap, it doesn’t seem like a name she’d use.

    Also, Scott’s escape from the X-Pit makes little sense as Kirby explains it, which probably didn’t bother 13-year old me a bit, but 63-year old me is quite confused. Still, 63-year old me is often confused, so we’ll just chalk it up to experience and move on. Thanks for this breakdown, Alan. Despite whatever stumbles may have had getting started, Mister Miracle turned into one of Kirby’s deepest and most complex creations and its interesting to see once again how it all began.

    Liked by 1 person

    • Alan Stewart · March 20, 2021

      I figured that Granny had been monitoring Scott for a while and that’s how she knew he’d taken on the Mister Miracle identity — though you’re right, her opting to use that moniker when she’s known him as Scott Free since his infancy is kinda awkward. I like your idea that she’s using it ironically, to taunt him as he falls into her trap.


  2. Ed · March 20, 2021

    Wow! Vince Colletta went from his usual fine-line illustrative style to a bold graphic inking style that no Jack Kirby fan should complain about. Not many inkers could adapt to different assignments by altering their way of drawing but Colletta did just that. I mean, Sinnott and Royer were great but they only had one way of doing things. Vinnie adapted to the requirements of the story and the genre. Check out his inks in Days of the Mob sometime.

    Liked by 1 person

  3. FredKey · March 20, 2021

    Among many reasons I find to be grouchy about comics these days (and kids on my lawn, doggone it) is that Scott Free is no longer Mr. Miracle. You can make someone else Mr. M, but the character is the man under the mask — the man who, with Orion, shares an exceptionally interesting backstory. Well, time to go yell at some youngsters.

    Liked by 1 person

    • Alan Stewart · March 20, 2021

      Yeah, kids today, amirite? But regarding Mister Miracle not being Scott Free anymore — well, Grant Morrison put Shilo Norman in the suit once before, about ten years ago, and it didn’t stick. So I figure we’ll see Scott become MM again one of these days, supposing we both live long enough. 🙂


  4. Capt. Moonbeam · March 20, 2021

    I’m down to my last few issues of MM and Jimmy Olsen, and then I’ll be done with my first run through the Fourth World. Unfortunately I don’t have hundreds of additional issues to look forward to. I’m glad that you are recapping these issues at the same time – synchronicity!

    Liked by 1 person

  5. bluesislove · March 23, 2021

    I absolutely loved Mr Miracle’s aero discs…..a great concept for an eight year old kid to imagine. I think of the four Fourth World Series, this one appealed to me the most because of all the gadgets and such.

    Since this was really my first exposure to Kirby, I sort of liked Colletta’s inks in this series. Actually my first Marvel exposure to Kirby was Thor inked by Colletta. To me, his style didn’t fit with every Kirby-drawn comic, but he was a good fit in some cases. I know he’s not everyone’s favorite, but he did have his place.

    Liked by 1 person

    • Alan Stewart · March 23, 2021

      As I’ve written elsewhere, I too am fond of Colletta’s inks over Kirby on both Thor and the Fourth World. I’m also with you in that I wouldn’t have wanted to see his fine-grained approach applied to a lot of Kirby’s other stuff — FF being the prime example — but it somehow seemed to work OK on “god” books. 🙂


  6. Stu Fischer · March 24, 2021

    Thank you Alan for spurring me on to a wonderful trip down memory lane. When I saw the name “Granny Goodness”, I actually exclaimed it out loud because it was a character I had not heard or thought about in well over four and a half decades. I agree that she couldn’t have been based on Phyllis Diller. I remember back in 1971, despite only being ten (and perhaps spurred on by the character of Grandy in the recent Green Lantern book) that Granny was inspired in some way by Martha Mitchell at least physically, but that’s probably because of the caricatures of Martha Mitchell in MAD magazine. This time around, my first thought was that Granny looked like Barbara Bush, which of course is impossible because not only would there be no reason for this, but Barbara Bush did not look that old in 1971. However, Granny did resemble SOMEONE to me and after thinking about it (now, not then) I wonder if Kirby had this character actress in his head at least subconsciously when creating Granny, https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Reta_Shaw

    As usual, in this issue Kirby constantly throws new concepts and creatures at you seemingly on every page. However, unlike in the concurrent issues of “Jimmy Olsen” and “The New Gods” where these concepts and creatures wind up slowing the plot down in exposition or are introduced with breathtaking splash pages which, while beautiful, do not advance the story, in this issue of “Mister Miracle” Kirby seamlessly weaves in all of the new concepts and creatures into the actual storyline without slowing it down. This issue is an action issue from start to finish, but unlike so many action issues where its only about fights with no characterization or plot, this issue has a lot of plot and characterization. It’s fast paced AND filling. I consider this an A plus issue by Kirby.

    Moreover, this issue reminds me of what a stroke of genius it was for Kirby to create Oberon as Scott’s “sidekick”. His observations are very realistic and entertaining. Oberon has always been one of my favorite supporting characters in comics.

    Bluesislove beat me to it. Those aero discs of Mr. Miracle were way cool. I think that I used to play act using them (on the ground, don’t worry, I’m obviously still here).

    Then I get to the last page and see a coming attractions for “The Paranoid Pill”! I haven’t thought of that issue for nearly 50 years. Apparently you aren’t going to blog about it, but I can read it on D.C. Universe on the 50th anniversary of its release.

    Thanks again for jogging my memory of why Mister Miracle was my favorite of the Fourth World books.

    Liked by 1 person

    • Alan Stewart · March 24, 2021

      Early on, I was considering devoting a full post to every single Fourth World issue, but I’m just not going to have the capacity to follow through on that — there are too many other comics from this period that I want to blog about, and there’s only so many posts I can crank out in a week! But don’t worry, I’ll have to at least briefly recap MM #3, since MM #4 won’t make sense otherwise — and I’m definitely blogging the debut of Big Barda. 🙂


  7. Pingback: Mister Miracle #4 (Sep.-Oct., 1971) | Attack of the 50 Year Old Comic Books
  8. Pingback: Forever People #9 (Jun.-Jul., 1972) | Attack of the 50 Year Old Comic Books
  9. Pingback: Mister Miracle #9 (Jul.-Aug., 1972) | Attack of the 50 Year Old Comic Books

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.