Howard the Duck #8 (January, 1977)

Your humble blogger would like to begin our look back at this rather special issue of Howard the Duck with a note of great admiration for its cover, which is probably my favorite in the whole run of the title.  Just lovely, iconic work from the title’s regular art team of Gene Colan and Steve Leialoha… plus Marvel Comics art director John Romita, who pencilled the central image of Howard, according to a 2023 Facebook post by Leialoha.  And thanks mostly to the faux newspaper headlines — doubtlessly the contribution of writer Steve Gerber — it’s a damn funny cover as well. 

Turning to the book’s opening splash page, we find our storytellers picking up their narrative in the immediate aftermath of “The Duck and the Defenders”, which had appeared in Marvel Treasury Edition #12 just a couple of weeks earlier:

As you’ll recall, the adventure Howard’s just now finished sharing with Marvel Comics’ premiere (OK, only) non-team featured the attempt of a group of would-be supervillains to make a name for themselves by assassinating the All Night Party’s candidate for U.S. president — i.e., Howard.  Will the help of Dr. Strange and friends, Howard and his companion, Beverly Switzler, have survived that experience — but as the page above makes ominously clear, while Dr. Angst and his absurd associates may have been the first out of the gate in the race to kill our hero, they won’t be anywhere near the last…

Fortunately for our dazed duo, help arrives in the very next moment in the form of their recent acquaintance/benefactor (?), country music star Dreyfuss Gulch, whose Rolls-Royce limousine screeches up to the curb.  “Hurry, y’all!” Gulch calls as he throws a door open.  “Muh bullet-proof glass will protect ya!  It’s been tested by North Carolina women!”

The “warped mind” in question belongs to one G.Q. Studley, whose secretary refuses to pass Howard through, explaining that her boss is currently in conference “about the Duck campaign”.  But when an understandably irate Howard (“Lady, I’m the blasted Duck!”) lunges across her desk to reach the switchboard, she calls for help — and Studley dispatches a couple of thuggish-looking escorts in response…

The reading audience of 1976 didn’t have to reach too far back to recall actual, real-life assassination attempts against either presidents or aspirants to the office; in 1972, independent candidate George Wallace had been paralyzed by an assassin’s bullet, while, more recently, President Gerald Ford had survived two separate attempts on his life, in 1974 and 1975.

I have no idea if Gerber (or Colan, for that matter) had any real-life model in mind for G.Q. Studley; Mad Genius Associates, on the other hand, was a familiar name to all of us Howard fans of ’76 who’d shelled out for an official HtD campaign button and/or portrait, because we’d had to send our money through the mail to “STEVE GERBER, c/o Mad Genius Associates, Room 806, 850 Seventh Avenue, New York, NY, 10019”.  At the time, I’m sure I assumed that MGA was just another name for Gerber himself; however, according to an interview given in 2019 by Gerber’s friend and fellow writer, David Anthony Kraft, that wasn’t quite the case:

Mad Genius was a studio partnership of Jim Salicrup and me. Steve was no part of that but Steve rented space from us and he was our friend so he was there a lot. We had an office on 7thAvenue and he needed a place to stuff buttons and hang out and watch Mary Hartman and whatnot. We had great times…

Alas, we’re not given a peek at the Marvel-Earth version of the Mad Genius Associates offices in this issue; rather, immediately following the phone booth scene, the storyline jumps forward in time to a point where MGA have clearly been on the job for a while…

While a good amount of Gerber’s political satire still hits home after fifty years, some of it really doesn’t hold up very well at all — due in large part, I believe, to our author’s having bought into a particular populist notion that (as frasersherman put it last month in a comment on HtD#7), “if it wasn’t for politicians, running the country would be perfectly simple.”  Indeed, if the last ten years of American political life have proved anything at all, it’s that the “wisdom of the common man” has been greatly exaggerated.  And so, though I’m disinclined to go through each and every one of Howard’s specific policy positions with which I have a quibble, there are a couple that I don’t feel I can let pass without comment.

For one, there’s Howard’s hot take on school busing, which in its implied bothsidesism is facile to the point of flippancy.  To my mind, Gerber’s “Send the parents for a ride!” is too cute by half, the words of someone who hasn’t really considered the issue with any kind of depth at all.  (And yes, I’m treating Howard as a mouthpiece for Gerber; based on everything I’ve ever read by or about the man, in interviews and so on, I think that’s fair.)

We’re on firmer footing with the following page, where Gerber ably lampoons both of 1976’s major party candidates — with Colan and Leialoha’s strong visual support, of course.  (This was Gerber’s second go at Gerald Ford within three months, following his use of our 38th prez as a supporting player in Defenders Annual #1 back in August.)

For those too young to remember, the real-life Walter Cronkite always signed off from his CBS evening newscast by saying, “And that’s the way it is;”  Walter Klondike’s addendum, “take it or leave it,” is, of course, pure Gerber.

This isn’t the first time we’ve seen this curly-haired, freckle-faced fellow before… nor, for that matter, is it the first time that Beverly has seen him, as he was the bellhop who delivered a cryptic message to her and Howard’s Plaza Hotel room in issue #7 (and whose hand she kissed in lieu of a tip).  Later, we saw him pass another such message to Howard while working as a waiter in a nightclub; then, one last time, hanging around the All Night Party’s convention floor as the delegates declared Howard their presidential nominee.  But while his initial actions could be construed as his trying to warn Howard and Beverly about the impending danger of the bomb that ultimately went off in that issue’s climax, the violent animosity towards all waterfowl that he demonstrates here makes one wish that Bev had a better memory for faces than she evidently does…

For any reader of this issue who still hasn’t worked out the pun behind Dreyfuss Gultch’s name, hopefully the shorter version so prominently displayed on his ranch’s sign will do the trick…

There was a time, about a year or so before this, when it seemed almost every month would bring readers another Marvel comic by Steve Gerber featuring at least one page of illustrated typeset text.  I believe that this is the first one such we’ve seen in quite a while, at least in an all-new story (though the recap/framing sequence created for the recent Marvel Treasury Edition #12 reprinting of Howard’s introduction in Fear #19 and Man-Thing #1 had used the device).

Nestled within this big mass of text is another position statement I feel obliged to comment on: Howard’s proposed solution to the question of amnesty for Vietnam War draft evaders, which is simply to provide Americans with “the facts” of the matter and then have them vote in a referendum.  Again, we have the populist assumption that, provided with sufficient information, the electorate will soberly exercise their Solomon-like “judgment” and make the right decision; and, again, the last ten years have proven that facts, by themselves, are not enough to convince a great many people about the truth of something, assuming you can even get them to pay attention to the facts in the first place.  (Besides which, putting every controversial issue to a popular vote isn’t the way representative democracy is supposed to work.)  In consideration of all of the above, Howard’s cocky “Revolutionary, huh?” doesn’t strike me as clever — just smug.

Oh, well.  We’ll move on… though not before noting yet another sighting of the Bellhop (as we’ll call him henceforth) among the attendees at the press conference.

In a manner reminiscent of his Doctor Strange work, Gene Colan abandons the standard rectangular-grid page layouts he’s used elsewhere in the issue just for the one page above, choosing instead to employ irregular, jagged panel borders that accentuate the chaotic nature of Howard and Beverly’s run through the “gauntlet of special interests”.

Ah, for the days when a plain vanilla sex scandal — two consenting adults, of different genders, caught on camera in a compromising position — was enough to end a political career.  The whole notion seems so quaint now, in an era in which one of our two major political parties has made it clear that concerns about personal sexual morality are only relevant in regards to the other side’s candidate.

But this is 1976 we’re talking about, here; and so I hope it’s not a spoiler for anyone out there when I break the news that this incident does, indeed, spell doom for Howard the Duck’s campaign for the presidency.  We’ll have more details when we do our next Howard-centered post, probably a couple of months from now — but I wouldn’t want any of you to go to bed tonight believing that the 39th President of the United States had been an irascible talking mallard, even on Marvel-Earth.

In closing, I’d like to express my hope that I haven’t been too hard here on Howard the Duck #8, which I still consider to be an extremely well drawn, and mostly well written, work of comic book entertainment.  Admittedly, I was a little surprised — and disappointed — to find, upon my re-reading of this comic book that I’ve held in great fondness for half a century, that it didn’t hold up as well as social commentary as I’d expected it would.  But I think that this is at least partly an inevitable result of how much the political environment has changed in the last fifty years.  Back in 1976, “liberal Republican” wasn’t yet an oxymoron, and while you could hardly say it didn’t matter whether Gerry Ford or Jimmy Carter won the White House, it didn’t seem like the fate of the nation (and maybe the world) was at stake.  Compare that to our present, extraordinarily fraught moment, when a sober historian like Timothy Snyder can write that next Tuesday’s U.S. midterms represent “probably the most consequential election since the eighteenth century”, and it doesn’t feel at all hyperbolic.

Still, the only way out is through, right?  So have a happy (and hopeful) Halloween, everyone, and I’ll see you on the far side of November 3rd.

19 comments

  1. Chris Green · 19 Days Ago

    Admittedly, not all the satire still stands up, but enough hits home, making this comic stand head and shoulders above anything else being published in the mainstream at the time.

    Plus, that Colan/Leialoha art is stunningly good.

    HtD was my favourite comic of the time by a long way (following the demise of Killraven and the end of Gerber’s run on Defenders) and I still revere it.

    And now that I’m a grumpy old man and my opinion of politicians and the political machine on both sides of the pond is at an all-time low, I find rereading this to be topical, to say the least.

  2. frednotfaith2 · 19 Days Ago

    Great write-up, Alan! Gotta say, much as I enjoyed this mag upon reading it 50 years ago, I fully agree with your comments regarding Gerber’s unfortunate political simple-mindedness on display. A majority of “the people”, particularly voting majorities, can be too easily swayed to do evil as much as good and that was true 50 years ago as it is today and given the major political scandals of just the previous 4 years, after Nixon had won one of the biggest political landslides in U.S. history, Gerber should have been well aware of how gullible the people can be at times.

    As to Gerber’s text pieces, I didn’t mind them at all back in the day, as they were generally entertaining or chilling, depending on the context of the story and I don’t think he went too overboard with them, unlike a certain Mr. Sim who nearly sank his own “funny animal” mag by filling several of them almost entirely with such texts which were more indicative of a very disturbed mind writing them than of any entertainment value.

    It is rather quaint to think of a politician’s ambitions being thwarted by a bogus sex scandal involving two unmarried consenting adults, even if one of them happened to be a talking duck!

  3. frasersherman · 19 Days Ago

    It’s not just that trusting to the wisdom of the people is overrated, it’s that justice isn’t decided by popular vote. Punishment or lack of punishment for draft dodgers shouldn’t be decided by, say, “the majority wants you in front of a firing squad.”

    I like the text pages. Much more efficient than a string of word balloons and easier to read.

    I too remembered Howard’s attacks as deeper than they seem to be. still a funny book.

  4. Man of Bronze · 19 Days Ago

    Funny stuff! They got a lot of mileage out of that Wrightson campaign button, as it appeared in an earlier issue, as well as multiple times in the Treasury Edition, and now here

  5. Ben Herman: In My Not So Humble Opinion · 19 Days Ago

    Agreed, Alan, with the benefit of hindsight (which of course is always 20:20) some of Steve Gerber’s observations & satire in this issue seem hopelessly naive after the hellacious past ten years of American politics. Howard the Duck #8 is definitely a product of its time in that respect.

    I really do wonder what Gerber would have made of Donald Trump and the Republican Party’s descent into utter corruption & degeneracy if he was still alive today. I kind of wish Gerber really was still with us, because we could certainly use an intelligent, clever, bold writer like him to skewer the GOP’s toxicity & criminality in a way a lot of others seem too afraid to.

    All that aside, HtD #8 is still a good, funny comic, with some really fantastic artwork by Gene Colan & Steve Leialoha.

    I blogged about the whole “Howard the Duck for President” storyline myself a decade ago…

    Howard the Duck for President – In My Not So Humble Opinion

  6. Steven McSheffrey · 19 Days Ago

    i was a completist back then but my enjoyment had waned by this point. I don’t dislike Colan’s art but it never seemed to quite fit the vibe of what was going on to me at least. I think Doctor Bong is the only clear memory I have of any of it.

    And why assassinate Howard? He’s not a US citizen so he can’t take office anyways.

  7. Rick Moore · 19 Days Ago

    At the risk of ruffling some feathers, this issue left a rather fowl taste in my mouth as the writer’s ambitions were not quite what they were “quacked” up to be.

    Bad puns aside, I would not have cared for this issue had it shown up on the spinner racks in “Sawmill Central.” Even at a rather naive age, Gerber’s politics would have had me curling my upper lip in distain.

    Alan hit the nail on the head with some discomforting views on the writer’s part. My argument is why even go there? Busing and draft dodging were two hot button issues at that time with clear divisions within the electorate. Why even touch on them? If you’re going for humor – and hey, we have a flipping anthropomorphic duck running for the Oval Office, don’t see how else you handle this! – why not pick topics with near universal support or opposition? A silly or funny position on pollution or corruption would have worked much better. Had this not been the largely dysfunctional Marvel of the mid-70’s, some editorial guidance could have nudged Gerber’s talents into a more appealing and ultimately, more enjoyable direction.

    Our host is also spot on that at this time, we simply cannot separate this comic from our nation’s pending mid-terms. Whether that pending blue wave is tidal and sweeping or falls sadly short, leaving the current party still in power, that we put ourselves into this situation and that there is any shred of doubt as to outcome of those midterms still cast us as a nation in a dismal light.

    But courtesy of Alan’s quality work, my morning is that much brighter. And for anyone who disagrees with my comments, let me suggest that they avoid the crowds and vote on Wednesday. (Kidding! Agree or disagree, I will strongly fight for everyone’s right to vote.)

  8. Don Goodrum · 19 Days Ago

    Well, since I’m usually the first to knock on Colan’s artwork during this period, let me say that his work on this issue of HTD is the best it’s been in a while. I think that’s a sign that he and Leialoha really enjoyed this issue and took the time to make it special. Then again, maybe Colan’s schedule opened up and he simply had more time to work this month. We’ll never know. Regardless, as simplistic as Gerber’s political philosophy might be, his heart was truly in the right place and I guess that’s what counts. Gerber may have gotten it wrong on bussing and draft dodging, but he also correctly identified the danger of special interests, big money donations (Elon Musk, anyone?) and the packaging of candidates in a way that doesn’t necessarily reflect their own personal ideas and beliefs. At least, we can all acknowledge the fact that Gerber cares enough to talk about and tell stories about these issues, even if (in that good old 20-20 hindsight), he doesn’t always hit the mark. Would that our political choices in 2026 were as benign as Gerry Ford and Jimmy Carter. Get out and vote this Tuesday, if you haven’t already! Thanks, Alan!

  9. frasersherman · 19 Days Ago

    I just finished Fantagraphics’ second Pogo collection, “Bona Fide Balderdash,” which includes the little possum getting dragged into becoming a presidential candidate. Gentler, not as in your face as Gerber, but a lot funnier.

    That said, I agree with Don — if his biting satire occasionally bit his own tongue, he was tackling topics few others in comics would have tried. In a way, I’d argue it’s more realistic — no candidate’s going to have the right stance on everything — though I’m quite sure that wasn’t his point.

    • frednotfaith2 · 18 Days Ago

      In the 1970s, as a kid growing into adolescence and then early adulthood, I was getting the available reprints. As of 1976, I’d missed many of the genuinely classic Lee/Kirby FF stories but at least had a good taste of them. And I had fewer samplings of Ditko runs on ASM & Dr. Strange, but I was getting many samplings of Marvel’s s superhero output from circa 1966 onwards, albeit typically missing 2 or 3 pages from the originals. I was also getting much of the new output, of course, and as I got older I got more of them but there was no way I could get all of them, even when they were “still only 35 cents” or whatever. In 1976, I was still primarily into the superheroes, especially those who had already been around for over a decade, and mainly those that didn’t stray too far from what I was used to. But gradually, I got tired of the variations of the old formulas and my appreciation of those writers who were trying to break out of the ruts grew. Starlin was certainly one although his output in the 1970s was relatively sparse, and he stood out as one of the very few writer/artists from ’73-75, before Kirby made his comeback. Englehart, Gerber, McGregor and Moench all developed styles that didn’t quite fit the Lee/Thomas model, which Conway, Wein & Wolfman tended to follow more closely. Gerber’s style most appealed to my ever more angsty, cynical adolescent self, particularly as his authorial voice was pretty distinct, often mixing humor and outrage at the stupidity of the world in his funhouse distortion of the real world, which while bereft of talking ducks, green-skinned big-muscled powerhouses and the like, was still full of absurdities and monstrosities in human form. Then and now, I didn’t agree with all of Gerber’s assertions, but I appreciated his going out on limbs to use comics as a medium of expressing himself rather than churning out formulaic pablum. As with all humans, sometimes he stumbled, but most times I found his work entertaining or at least fascinating.

  10. Mike Breen · 19 Days Ago

    Have to thank Alan for writing the review I would have written (although mine would not have been so well done). Thank you mate!

    Agree with pretty much everything Alan said and much of the comments that follow. As has been noted before, Gerber should be celebrated for his efforts even if he didn’t always hit his targets. This issue in particular feels like it’s showing its age, and I liked it much more 50 years ago than I do now. Howard (Gerber)’s proposed policies do seem simplistic and naive, especially in light of what is happening for you guys in the US right now.

    Whenever the current political situation rears its (very) ugly head, all I can do is wish you guys (and all of us) a better and brighter future – hopefully sometime soon.

  11. Ben Herman: In My Not So Humble Opinion · 15 Days Ago

    I’ve been a bundle of nerves for the past week and a half, ever since early voting started here in New York State. I was really trying to steel myself for the worst possible outcome. So, when I was reading Alan’s election-related post about Howard the Duck’s ill-fated Presidential bid this past Saturday morning, all I could focus on was the pervasive feeling of doom I felt hovering over this country.

    Well, it’s now Wednesday, November 4th, the day after Election Day, and I feel like I can finally breathe again. I’m thrilled to see just how much was accomplished yesterday. Of course, now the hard work really begins. There is so damn much damage that needs to be repaired, so much evil and corruption that needs to be fought.

    But for now I’ll allow myself to say it… BLUE WAVE!!!!!

    Oh, yeah, back on topic. My absolute favorite line from this issue remains “My god, he’s telling the truth! He’ll be dead in a week!” 🙂

    • Man of Bronze · 14 Days Ago

      Both sides of the aisle talk about each other in the exact same way. Remarkable.

      • Alan Stewart · 14 Days Ago

        To the extent that that’s even true, MoB, it doesn’t prove that neither side is correct.

        • Man of Bronze · 14 Days Ago

          “Oh, the humanity!” 😉

        • Mike Breen · 14 Days Ago

          Very well said.

  12. Mike Breen · 14 Days Ago

    I was replying to Alan.

    • Man of Bronze · 12 Days Ago

      Life is full of ironies, and politics are no exception. In the US, after the Republicans swept the presidency, house, and senate two years ago, a blue waves of Dems took the house and senate this month. Meanwhile, in the UK the Labour Party lost 1400 seats this year.

      The tide goes in and out, in and out.

      • Spiritof64 · 10 Days Ago

        A favourite HTD issue; one I could mostly relate to/ understand at the time ( not at all sure what the bussing topic was about though) and some top Colan-Leialoha art. Splash page was especially appealing… nice of Clea to put in an appearance!

        And as ever, some info that otherwise unknown for 50 years….never would have guessed that HTD on the wonderful cover was done by Romita ( and having reacquainted myself with the original draft in the Treasury…really glad that Jazzy Jonny stepped in!).

Leave a Reply