Justice League of America #97 (March, 1972)

During the nearly yearlong period (June, 1971 through April, 1972) that DC Comics published most of their books in a giant-sized, 25-cent format, Justice League of America presented a particular sort of challenge for its editor, Julius Schwartz.  The problem arose from the fact that the new, larger format called for a certain amount of reprint material — generally, 13 to 15 pages’ worth — to fill out each issue.  And whereas for Schwartz’s other books, such as Batman, Flash, Green Lantern, and Superman, there was a ready archive of suitable old stories featuring the titular stars, the same wasn’t true for JLA, which from the beginning had been devoted to issue-length tales of more than 20 pages.  Such stories weren’t going to work as backups in the new format without being either cut in half or severely abridged, neither of which options seems to have appealed to the veteran editor. 

As we’ve covered in previous posts, Schwartz initially relied on a hodgepodge of oddities that could be at least thematically linked to the JLA, including a mid-’60s Flash story where the speedster temporarily becomes “The One-Man Justice League!” (pretty much a no-brainer) and an early-’50s “Knights of the Galaxy” adventure from Mystery in Space (um… because they were a team, I guess?), before ultimately settling on a steady diet of ’40s tales featuring the members of the Justice Society of America in solo action.  That made a kind of sense, as JLA was the closest thing that most of DC’s Golden Age greats had to a home in 1971-72; but this reader, at least, would have preferred for the Justice League of America comic book to feature the Justice League of America all the way through, cover to cover.

And in January, 1972, I finally got my wish — as Schwartz (or JLA writer Mike Friedrich, or maybe someone else in the DC offices altogether) had the bright idea to retell a tale of the League’s past — and to incorporate pages from the story’s original presentation into this retelling.  And it wasn’t just any old JLA story, either — as the banner below the cover image by Neal Adams and Murphy Anderson proclaimed, it was nothing less than “The Origin of the Justice League!”

And while some fans might have looked askance at DC’s presenting a rehashed, partially reprinted old story, framed by a modest amount of all-new material, like it was some sort of event — “A 37-Page Super-Star Spectacular!”, no less — my fourteen-year-old self was not one of them.  Though I had begun reading Justice League of America during the era it was still being produced by the original creative team of Gardner Fox (writer), Mike Sekowsky (penciller) and Bernard Sachs (inker), their JLA origin story in issue #9 had come out in late 1961, when I was but a wee lad of four.  Even the story’s one and only reprinting to date, in 80 Page Giant Magazine #8 (“More Secret Origins”), had been published in January, 1965, a good seven months before I bought my first DC comic book.  So not only had I never read the Justice League’s origin story, but I also had no reason to assume it would be reprinted again anytime soon; its presentation here thus did feel like something special, at least to me.

And there was something else which made JLA #97 special, aside from its revisiting of the team’s foundational adventure; “The Day the Earth Screams” was the second chapter of the first three-parter in the title’s history.  For that reason, we’ll be taking a look at the preceding issue, #96, before digging into our main topic of discussion today.

Actually, we’ll be going back further even than that, as scripter Friedrich had begun laying the groundwork for the “Starbreaker trilogy” as early as #94.  As you may recall from our post about that comic last September, towards the end of “Where Strikes Demonfang?” there was a one-page scene near the end in which Flash, Green Lantern, and Hawkman, responding to an emergency alert from Black Canary that something was interfering with the signal transmission of the team’s new teleportation machine, vanished en route to the JLA’s satellite headquarters… after attempting to use the ailing teleporter.  Yeah, smart move, guys.

This story thread continued into the next issue, though only as a subplot, as the main action of issue #95 found the non-missing members of the team involved with “The Private War of Johnny Dune!”  Over the course of the narrative, however, Batman did manage to deduce that the teleporter disruption had been caused by the signal’s having been intercepted by a Zeta-Beam — you know, the ray that instantaneously transports Adam Strange from Earth to the faraway planet Rann every so often.  Then, immediately after Batman’s announcement of his discovery, the JLA received an incoming power-ring transmission from Green Lantern, confirming that he and the others had indeed found themselves in their friend Adam’s usual stomping grounds — and what’s more, they’d arrived in the middle of a crisis, one that had the potential to threaten Earth as well as Rann.  At the story’s end, Superman was shown streaking through space en route to the latter planet — which, Rann being 26 trillion miles distant from Earth, probably took him at least an hour or two.

Friedrich — with his usual artistic collaborators, penciller Dick Dillin and inker Joe Giella — picks up the story in JLA #96’s “The Coming of — Starbreaker!”  In its opening scene, Superman’s telescopic vision allows him to locate his teammates even before he makes planetfall:

Superman expects to make quick work of these bugs, but finds they’re tougher than they look — among their other attributes, they’re able to shoot jets of flame that are “like prominences of a red sun“.  Ultimately, however, he’s able to fool them into firing their jets at each other, causing them to explode.

Once that immediate danger is taken care of, Supes’ pals begin to fill him in on what’s been going on.  Rann is currently under assault by a villain known as Starbreaker, they say, whose nature and background are helpfully explained by GL’s power ring:

Good God!” exclaims Superman.  “This Starbreaker is like a cosmic vampire — living off the life-energies of shattered worlds!”  You said it, Big Blue — which makes him the latest in a series of recent comic-book villains who, while they may not technically be vampires of the traditional undead variety (Starbreaker, for example, really has more in common with Galactus than he does with Dracula), are at least now allowed to be referred to by the previously verboten “V” word, thanks to the relaxation of the Comics Code Authority’s rules regarding horror in early 1971.*

Setting aside the vampiric aspect for a moment, Starbreaker’s modus operandi, as outlined here by Friedrich, seems more than a little sketchy.  The conflation of physical energy (such as that released by “the crashing of planet-and-sun”) with the psychic variety (that contained in “minds and emotions”) is conceptually problematic to begin with; but even if one accepts that idea, the notion that the latter would be more potent than the former is rather hard to swallow — at least if we’re talking about the kind of energy that can be auctioned off “to the highest bidder”.  (When Starbreaker was brought back in 1992, writer-artist Dan Jurgens did a pretty good job of cleaning all this up by making a clear distinction between the two types of energy, and establishing that Starbreaker used each for different purposes; in 1972, however, I’m afraid we’re on our own.)

It’s also not clear how the villain’s “mechanix bugs” can cause planets to jump out of their orbits and hurtle into their suns, simply by crawling around and wreaking destruction.  But we’ll have to roll with it — as will our four Justice Leaguers, because Green Lantern’s ring has detected two more sites on Rann currently under bug attack.  Naturally, in time-honored JLA fashion, the heroes split into teams to take on these menaces…

Then, in a novel twist, Starbreaker — who’s been monitoring events from his spaceship — splits himself in two in response.  (Well, actually, he creates “energy-duplicates” of himself, but close enough…)

Unfortunately for Starbreaker, this strategy backfires — despite the fact that he’s able to absorb vast amounts of energy (physical and psychic) and discharge it as force blasts, not to mention that he has (in his own words) “solved the problem of linking science and magic” (very handy, especially when you’re fighting Superman), dividing his strength in two ultimately allows both teams of JLAers to get the upper hand and defeat his surrogates (and his bugs, as well), in successive chapters.

After coming back together, our victorious heroes are greeted not only by a thankful Rannian populace, but also by Adam Strange, who managed to catch the next Zeta-Beam off of Earth — arriving too late to help in the fight, obviously, but still in time for a quick cameo (and for a quick plug for his reprinted exploits then appearing in Strange Adventures)…

Where are the defeated Starbreakers disappearing to?  Why, to the spaceship where awaits their furious “daddy” — who takes the time to slap both his disappointing progeny across their miserable faces, right before reverting them back to raw energy and re-absorbing them…

With Starbreaker’s grim promise still ringing in our metaphorical ears, we’ll now segue from December, 1971’s Justice League of America #96 right into January, 1972’s issue #97:

Hawkman precedes to give a slightly abridged version of the Starbreaker briefing provided by Green Lantern’s power ring in the last issue, wrapping up with the following:

As bummed out as all these JLAers are by Hawkman’s little presentation, Green Arrow, at least, is still eager to head down to Earth to get ready to take Starbreaker on — but Hawkman says there’s no point in doing so for the moment, as “Superman, Flash, and Green Lantern are on a 24-hour super-alert — sentinels for Starbreaker’s slightest move!”

And after a brief scene in which our villain charges himself up by making a quick snack out of the emissary of an alien dictator who’s dared to question the energy broker’s going rates, Starbreaker does indeed finally make his move on planet Earth — and it’s not at all what you’d call “slight”:

With Flash out for the count, Green Lantern steps up to take his shot — but Starbreaker easily turns GL’s “two-way punch” back against him:

If the rest of the JLA were kind of mopey before, the return to the satellite of their thoroughly whipped “three top super-stars” (in Aquaman’s phrase) leaves them completely demoralized.  “If these guys can’t save Earth,” moans the Atom, “what could we minor Leaguers do?

It’s pretty easy to look at this scene now and think, “Really?  With the Earth facing total destruction, you guys figure that now’s the time to watch an old video?”  But that’s the way we fans rolled back in 1972.  (Or maybe it’s just the way your humble blogger rolled, at age 14.)

One of the more clever aspects of this story’s integration of the JLA #9 material is how it takes advantage of the original tale’s structure.  As it is in JLA $97, the League’s origin was presented in #9 within a narrative frame, as the members who were around for the events described them to those that weren’t (i.e., “mascot” Snapper Carr [who first met the League in Brave and the Bold #28] and Green Arrow [who joined the team in JLA #4]), on the occasion of the team’s third anniversary.  In the present retelling, using the device of having the original League members relate the story on tape allows for the inclusion of the original story’s rotating first-person narration.

“Its blue beams must be what’s getting everyone stoned!”  Yeah, we saw what you did there, Mr. Friedrich.  (Though it probably went right over my younger self’s head in 1972.)  In case you’re wondering, Gardner Fox’s original line was, “Those blue beams from his eyes must be what causes everyone to become stony!”

With the next page comes this issue’s first reprinted content, straight from JLA #9’s “The Origin of the Justice League!”, where it appeared as page 5.  The visual transition from Dillin-Giella to Sekowsky-Sachs is hardly seamless, but that’s sort of the point — the presence of the vintage material is actually part of this issue’s appeal (at least theoretically), so one ought to be able to recognize it when shows up.  (And in any event, it’s a less jarring stylistic shift than the one we had between Dillin-Giella and Neal Adams in JLA #94, just a few months back.)

Having gleaned from the stone giant’s mind that he was vulnerable at a particular spot on his noggin, the Martian Manhunter delivered a mighty wallop to that precise point, and…

At this point in JLA #9, J’onn J’onzz turned the narrative over to Aquaman, and so the same thing happens here, as the Friedrich-Dillin-Giella team returns for a single panel:

The King of the Seven Seas explains how he swam to investigate the weird phenomenon that was turning the ocean’s living creatures to glass, only to find himself beginning to go glassy as well.  Just about then, the Appellaxian showed up…

But even as the trunkfish swam to the attack, Aquaman was calling in more help, such as “the Indian trigger-fish, the Australian Ceratodus… the coffer, and the gurnard, among others…”  (Nothing says “DC in the Silver Age” quite like the inclusion of a few random morsels of scientific fact, which provide the young reader with the vague but pleasant impression that they’re learning something [though without the unpleasant associations of homework].  Never mind that one of the kinds of fish listed [the Australian Ceratodus or lungfish] is a freshwater fish that wouldn’t be caught dead in the Indian Ocean… actually, on second thought, “dead” is the only way it would be caught there.)

As it turns out, it’s good that Aquaman wasn’t depending just on the trunkfish, as their assault failed miserably when the Appellaxian’s eye-beams turned them all to glass.  But the others he’d called — “the noisemakers of the fish family”, of which he hoped at least one would be able to shatter the glass alien with its characteristic sound — fared little better, at least at first…

Gee, J’onn and Aquaman showing up at the same time was quite the coincidence, huh?  I guess stranger things have happened, though.  Anyway, moving on…

Wonder Woman watched in horror as the tape-viewer showed her how the weird being’s radiation had turned all her fellow Amazons, including her mom, Queen Hippolyta, into globs of liquid mercury, which proceeded to follow their progenitor towards the sea…

Even if Diana couldn’t hurl the creature into outer space, she could swing it around and around, really, really fast…

So WW managed to arrived at the same time as our previous two heroes, eh?  Well, that does seem rather unlikely… but not impossible, I suppose.

Unfortunately, Green Lantern’s protective energy sheath wasn’t quite up to the task of shielding him from the effects of the alien radiation — I guess it was all that yellow — and he too began to turn into a big golden bird.  But then he realized that they were flying over Victoria Falls, and he got an idea…

Four superheroes all arriving at the same time?  Well, er… let’s see, now…  hm.

The Flash managed to counter the radiation’s effects, at least temporarily, by vibrating at high speed, but dousing the alien’s flame proved more difficult.  After a column of water our hero whipped up out of the nearby Lake Como was instantly turned to steam, the Fastest Man Alive scooted across the Mediterranean Sea to scoop up some sand from the Sahara Desert…

The panels above represent the last of the issue’s material pulled directly from Justice League of America #9 — with #97’s reprint quota having now been filled at 13 pages (more or less), the remainder of the JLA’s origin story will be (re)told by the book’s current creative team.

OK, here’s your rationale for these five proto-Leaguers all arriving on the Carolina seashore (and is that North or South Carolina, I wonder?) just a few seconds apart from each other: it’s called narrative convenience.

J’onn’s strategy became apparent in the next moment, as the Flash’s bumping into Wonder Woman moved her — or at least her left side — into the path of Green Lantern’s bark-removing power-ring beam…

Friedrich’s version of this scene differs from Fox’s in one important respect.  In the retelling, Wonder Woman’s lasso merely planes the wood-creature “down to its bare essence”; in the original, however (as shown below), the alien is reduced to “a pile of slivers and splinters”:

Why the change?  It seems unlikely that the Comics Code Authority could have had anything to do with it, seeing as how they’d passed the story through in both its original 1961 presentation and its 1965 reprinting.  And JLA editor Julius Schwartz had been on hand for both those occasions, as well.  The most probable answer, then, is that writer Mike Friedrich was uncomfortable with having Wonder Woman cause the (apparent) death of a sentient being — even if said being was a bad guy, and made of wood, to boot. (UPDATE 1/22/22, 9:30 pm:  As pointed out by reader brucesfl in his comment below, Friedrich did in fact later claim responsibility for making the change, stating in an interview for the 2005 book Justice League Companion: “I felt that good guys don’t kill people.”)

After the Martian Manhunter filled in his costumed colleagues on what he’d learned from the mind of the stone Appellaxian, all five heroes decided to head to Greenland to deal with the sixth and final meteor — “together!

“After returning the inactivated meteor-beings to their own world…”  There’s a similar, but not identical line on the last page of the original story, where Wonder Woman tells Snapper Carr, “We returned such meteor-beings as we could to their own world, keeping the pile of splinters as a souvenir!” (italics mine).  You can see now, I hope, why Friedrich felt he needed to make an adjustment regarding the disposition of the splintered wood-creature, whereas he didn’t for the shattered glass-being, or for the vaporized mercury-person; just speaking for myself, I’m not all that keen on the idea of the JLA killing a foe and keeping their mortal remains as a trophy, either.

Back in the Silver Age, writers had Superman squeezing lumps of coal into diamonds so often that it could almost be considered a distinct superpower — but reversing the process?  Not so much.  Intriguingly, in Fox’s original script, the Man of Steel’s means for accomplishing this feat wasn’t explained at all, whereas Friedrich’s at least makes an attempt.  To wit, on page 35 of the current story, Supes’ thought balloon tells us, “The super-heat I’m causing by friction is breaking down the menace’s molecules — changing it from diamond to coal“; meanwhile, the corresponding line in Fox’s version simply has Superman-the-narrator make the flat statement, “I reduced the dangerous diamond menace to a mere chunk of coal”.  Um, OK, then.  Frankly, you can easily understand why Snapper would want to ask a follow-up question; but in JLA #9, the Action Ace’s answer comes across less as a “priceless crack”, and more of a blow-off (probably because Fox didn’t actually have an answer):

I’m not at all sure that Friedrich’s version really makes more sense than Fox’s, scientifically speaking — but you’ve got to give the younger author points for at least trying.

And with the unexpected advent of Sargon the Sorcerer, we come to the end of this Very Special Issue of Justice League of America.  If you’re curious, the original version of “The Origin of the Justice League!” ran 26 pages, with roughly four of those devoted to the framing sequence; JLA #97’s version, which for argument’s sake we’ll say begins with Hawkman’s inspirational speech on page 11 and runs through page 36, is practically the same length.  So, as far as storytelling efficiency goes, it’s pretty much a wash between the two.

I enjoyed this issue back in 1972, and I still find it entertaining today (though I’ll be the first to acknowledge that it shows its age, in both its fifty-year-old and sixty-one-year-old parts).  But, of course, it’s not a complete reading experience on its own, being the middle part of a trilogy — and so, seeing as how we covered this story’s first chapter earlier in the post, I figure we might as well go ahead and tackle issue #98’s concluding segment here as well.  (Especially since there’s no way we’re going to be able to squeeze it into what’s looking like a very packed blogging schedule in March.)  Before we do, however, we should probably say a few words about Sargon.

Sargon the Sorcerer made his debut in All-American Comics #26 (May, 1941); the creation of writer John B. Wentworth and artist Howard Purcell, he was one of a number of Golden Age heroes whose stage-magician-with-real-magic-powers shtick was ultimately derived from Lee Falk’s popular comic-strip hero, Mandrake the Magician.  Though he never became as well-known as many of his fellow 1940s-era crusaders, Sargon proved to be a pretty durable second-stringer, holding down his A-AC slot for twenty-five issues before moving on — first to a brief stint in Comic Cavalcade, then settling in for a four-year run in Sensation Comics before taking his final bow in the 37th issue of Green Lantern (1941 series), cover-dated March-April, 1949.  Not a bad showing at all, really.

Following that last adventure, Sargon languished for a full twenty years, until he was brought back in Flash #186 (Mar., 1969) by a young writer named, you guessed it, Mike Friedrich.  Intriguingly, Friedrich seems to have felt (at least initially) that Sargon would be more interesting as a villain, and thus had him team up with the Scarlet Speedster’s arch-foe from the future, the Reverse-Flash.  As the Sorcerer explained to his new ally: “For twenty years I fought on the side of the law!  However, when I matured, I decided it was a waste of my special talent…”  Such self-assurance notwithstanding, however, by as early as the conclusion of his second Flash outing (in another Friedrich-scripted tale, published in issue #207 [Jun., 1971]), the one-time good guy was definitely having second thoughts regarding his new path… which is how things stand at the beginning of JLA #98’s “No More Tomorrows!”:

Using the power of his Ruby of Life, Sargon easily counters the Atom’s attack, and even staggers Superman.  He protests to the Leaguers that he’s on their side — “Despite our differences, we have a common enemy — Starbreaker!” — but the heroes remain skeptical, especially Green Arrow, who keeps an arrow notched and pointed at the Sorcerer’s chest…

At this point, we’re going to skip over the next ten pages, which are completely extraneous to the main plot (not only does Starbreaker not show up even once, but none of the new characters we meet even appear to be aware that the whole planet is currently facing destruction) — existing, it seems, only so that Friedrich can stretch his story over three issues.  Seriously, you could easily ditch the whole “quest for the ‘two counterparts’ of the Ruby of Life” business, and it would have no impact on anything that happens once the League comes back together; and indeed, that’s just what we’re going to do, at least to the extent possible.  I thus sincerely hope you’ll take my word for it that the parallel expeditions to “tropical Sierra Verde” and “the mountains of southern Germany” worked out just as Sargon expected, because we’re about to jump right to…

Is it just me, or does the close-up of Supergirl in that last panel look like it was drawn by someone other than Dillin and Giella?  What say ye, faithful readers?

Yeah, Starbreaker’s going to split himself up again, because that worked so well for him the last time.  It seems a pretty boneheaded move on the villain’s part — but there’s an in-story explanation for it, as we’ll see a bit further on.

And besides, this development allows Friedrich to split the JLA up into smaller units one last time — scratching an itch the writer seems to have had pretty bad all through this storyline…

If you, like Flash, recognize that very colorful building in the next to last panel above, it may just be that you’ve read our post about Flash #203 from back in December, 2020.

I love the touch of having Hawkman knock Starbreaker right out of the panel borders; it’s the sort of visual playfulness we don’t really see all that often from Dick Dillin.

I think it’s supposed to be wood for a vampire, silver for a werewolf — but what the hell, it’s all make-believe, right?

Meanwhile, back in the present — where only a moment has passed since their teammates blinked out of sight — Superman and Batman watch bemusedly as their badly weakened foe falls to his hands and knees.  But Starbreaker’s still not ready to concede defeat, and drawing on his “deepest reserves” of power, he makes one last stab at victory — by attempting to bury Superman in Central City’s accumulated trash.  Is this guy kidding?

You might say that Supes is Hulking out, here…

As we noted earlier, Starbreaker would return to bedevil the JLA again one day… but not for twenty years.  It seems the Guardians of the Universe would do a better job of keeping him on ice than they could ever mange with, say, Sinestro.

And Sargon the Sorcerer?  He’d (mostly) stay on the straight and narrow from this point on… all the way up to his fiery death in Swamp Thing #50 (Jul., 1986).

And there you have it — the first three-part storyline in Justice League of America‘s history.  Somewhat ironically, it would have the status of being the only such storyline for just one more issue, as JLA #100 would see the beginning of yet another trilogy.

Mike Friedrich wouldn’t be around for that one, however, as #99 would feature his last script for Justice League of America.  The “Next Issue” blurb shown above makes “Seeds of Destruction!” sound intriguing, and the book’s Nick Cardy cover shown at right is appealing as well.  Unfortunately, I can’t tell you much more about it than that, as I not only didn’t buy the book upon its original release in April, 1972, but also never acquired it as a back issue — and to this date I still haven’t actually read the story.  (In my defense, it’s only been reprinted twice, and both times as part of a large anthology, surrounded by JLA stories I have read and don’t need to re-acquire.  One of these days, though…)

JLA #98 was thus my last Mike Friedrich issue; and so, I’m going to take the opportunity provided by this post for a few last comments regarding Friedrich’s run on Justice League of America, even though it’s still January and the first issue of JLA written by his successor, Len Wein, won’t be eligible for blogging about until June.  I know that the “Friedrich era” of JLA has its detractors — some of whom have shared their less-than-glowing opinions of the work in comments on this very blog — and I myself recognize its flaws (as I believe should be obvious to anyone who’s read this post up to this point).  Still, for all of their sometimes clunky plotting, frequent emotional excesses, and occasionally overwrought prose, I find Friedrich’s stories in general to be more memorable than most (though surely not all) of those that followed them in this title, on through the remainder of the Bronze Age of Comics.  From my perspective, Friedrich brought a sense of personal investment and commitment to his work here that I simply value more than I do airtight plotting and other markers of “professional” writing.  Others’ mileage will surely vary… and that’s just fine, as far as I’m concerned.

Ironically, some of the qualities I admire in Friedrich’s JLA stories, as well as in his other work for DC, may have been in part responsible for the writer’s leaving DC for Marvel.  In an interview with Michael Eury for the book Justice League Companion (TwoMorrows, 2005), Friedrich explained:

…I was just really not in sync with Julie [Schwartz].  I remember very, very clearly Julie telling me that my work was too much like Marvel; and all this time, Roy Thomas is telling me, “Any time you want to come work here [at Marvel], let me know.”  And so at some point, I took him up on it.  I just said, “Listen, I’d like to start working here.  Is there regular work?”  And [Marvel] handed me a silver platter…

Perhaps even more ironically, much of the work that Friedrich went on to produce for Marvel was, at least in your humble blogger’s opinion, less personal, and ultimately, less memorable, than what he’d done at DC.  Again, his interview with Eury hints at at least one possible reason:

…as a writer, going to Marvel was great and it was terrible at the same time.  Going to Marvel for me was making more money, having more fun for a while.  But then, I’m no longer writing my heartfelt characters.  I didn’t care about Iron Man the way I cared about Green Lantern.  [At Marvel], I’m no longer writing about my childhood heroes.  It’d become a job, and although it was a really good job, but I couldn’t sustain it much for more than a couple of years.

Writing for love versus writing for money.  Maybe it doesn’t always make a difference in the quality of the work; but I think it’s fair to say that sometimes, at least, it actually does.

Of course, not that all of Mike Friedrich’s writing for Marvel was forgettable; any list of credits that includes scripting the story that introduced Thanos and Drax the Destroyer (albeit from a Jim Starlin plot) is hardly one to be dismissed.  And his time spent writing for Marvel hardly represented the end of Friedrich’s contributions to the comics medium, either.  Arguably, his most significant achievement in the field was yet to come, with his founding of Star*Reach Productions, the pioneering “ground-level” comic book publisher.

But that event, of course, is still a few years out from our present frame of reference.  Here’s hoping that you, I, and this blog are all still around when it comes time for us to discuss Star*Reach and its kindred, later this decade.

 

*Others in this series (in order of their first published appearance) include Mantis from Forever People, Morbius from Amazing Spider-Man, and Count Dragorin from Jimmy Olsen.

20 comments

  1. Jim Henry · January 22

    Great review. It’s really jarring to see this Justice League story alongside the Neal Adams and Barry Smith Avengers classics which were released at the same time

    Liked by 1 person

  2. DontheArtistformerlyknownasfrodo628 · January 22

    I’ve never seen this story before that I remember, but I could have sworn the JLA’s first mission together involved fighting Starro. Anybody know what I’m thinking of? I don’t know. I’m getting old and my mind is about as clunky as a Mike Friedrich metaphor.

    The thing that kills me about the JLA in this particular time period-and it bothers me NOW; it did not bother 14-year-old me THEN-is that most of the menaces that the group faced were so ordinary. I know that both the JLA, the Avengers, the Legion and most of the other large hero teams in those days liked to separate everyone up and send smaller teams out on smaller missions in the context of the story, but only in the JLA books did that seem superfluous and time-wasting. If the JLA had landed on Starbreaker at full power, truly working as a team and not as each group member taking their turn at bat as most often seemed to be the case, In the original 1961 JLA origin story, the team had to split up to face each of the warlords fighting to conquer the Earth, but in the 1972 story, it seems like Starbreaker split himself up because the JLA did, not the other way around.

    And what about Starbreaker? As Freidrich puts it, he’s the most powerful creature in the galaxy. And yet, at a time when the “Marvelous Competition” is giving us Galactus and Dormammu and even Annihilus, Friedrich is giving us just another guy…in a suit. SIGH. I dunno, I realize that there’s a lot of underwhelming stuff to be found in Bronze Age comics, but these JLA stories seem to be the most underwhelming of a truly underwhelming lot. I love me some DC, but in the early seventies, with the exception of Kirby and O’Neill and Adams on Batman, they just weren’t swinging hard enough for the bleachers.

    Liked by 1 person

    • Marcus · January 22

      The JLA fought Starro in Brave and the Bold #28, the first JLA story. As Alan points out, they didn’t get an origin till JLA #9.

      Liked by 2 people

  3. frednotfaith2 · January 22

    Having read most Avengers stories from the Silver & Bronze ages, to my recall it was rather rare that they purposely split off during the course of the story, although Thomas in particular did that a few times purposely aping the JLA’s standard operating procedure. And Englehart did it for his Avengers/Defenders clash, but when it came to his Zodiac story a few months later, he didn’t have the Avengers split up to show them in separate stories taking on factions of the Zodiac cartel, although the Zodiac itself split up into competing factions.
    Admittedly, I only ever got a few JLA comics. Just wasn’t my cup of tea, and this three-parter wouldn’t have changed my mind about that. Knowing that by this point, Marvel had been doing three, four or even more multi-issue stories since 1965, seems strange that it took this long for the first 3-issue story to appear in the JLA — and I presume most if not all other DC titles, not counting Kriby’s 4th World series, had yet to break the two-issue story barrier. I can understand the reluctance of the top brass at DC to allow such stories as too often readers might miss an issue and most likely preferred done-in-ones to even two-parters. In my case, while I was certainly annoyed when I missed an issue that was part of a multi-issue story, I still preferred the greater complexity and drama such stories allowed. I certainly didn’t mind the occasional one-issue story, but a long string of them usually got very monotonous and boring, IMO, most becoming too obviously formulaic. And if in every Avengers story, they always split up to take on different foes or, as in this JLA tale, different aspects of the same foe, I likely wouldn’t have kept collecting the series as long as I did.

    Liked by 3 people

  4. Alan, I was wondering if you were going to do a write-up on this issue. My mother’s cousin Celia gave this to me as a gift in 1994. She knew I read comic books and I guess she found it in a thrift store, along with an old Avengers special. I was a senior in high school. I was 17 years old, so not much older than you were when it first came out.

    From what I recall, I really did not find the transition between the new artwork by Dillin & Giella and the reprinted artwork by Sekowsky & Sachs to be at all jarring. There were some pages that at the time I really thought were reprinted from JLA #9 but which I now know were Dillin & Giella’s retelling of those events. Nowadays at 45 years old, possessing much more of a familiarity with the artists’ styles, it’s much more apparent to me, but I still think the new material and reprints mesh together fairly well.

    A few years after this issue was given to me I got it signed by Joe Giella and Julius Schwartz at a comic con in upstate New York.

    Regarding Starbreaker, I am a bit surprised that he did not go on to become a bigger villain in the DCU. Perhaps it was down to what DontheArtist cites above, in that Starbreaker’s design is a bit, well, pedestrian. Dillin was a really good, solid, effective penciler & storyteller, but I’ve never found him to be an especially strong character designer. A cosmic-powered menace who is across between Dracula and Galactus sounds like a good concept. Maybe if Starbreaker got a redesign he could become a more prominent adversary for the Justice League or Green Lantern Corps.

    I’m guessing one of the reasons why there was a quest by the JLA to find the counterparts to Sargon’s gem (other than to make sure the story was long enough) was so that the Sorcerer would not come across as such a deus ex machina by just handing them they key to defeating Starbreaker.

    Liked by 1 person

  5. markwaid · January 22

    As regards Supergirl, yeah, absolutely–clearly Dillin and Giella both had been working with outdated reference, and someone in production was handed a copy of a current Oksner Supergirl story and drafted to make the fix. (The shot’s definitely modeled on Oksner, but (a) it’s too loose to be him, and (b) eleventh-hour SOP in those pre-digital days was to just have someone in the Production Department make a quick fix rather than go to the trouble of asking for a redraw or conscript a more appropriate artist–it’s unlikely Oksner was just standing around the DC offices at the time.)

    Liked by 2 people

    • Alan Stewart · January 22

      Ah, that makes sense. This being the era when Mike Sekowsky had readers submitting new costume designs for Kara over in Adventure, I can see how it would be hard for artists on other books to keep current on her look. 🙂

      Liked by 1 person

  6. crustymud · January 22

    I understand your feelings here, Alan. Friedrich’s take feels like the first “modern” treatment of the team, and an even sharper break from formula than O’Neil’s tenure had been. Even with all his flaws (and those flaws were many, as you point out), Friedrich gave us stories that felt refreshing in a way that was sorely needed for the JLA.

    Liked by 3 people

  7. Scott · January 22

    Thanks for the great review, as always Alan. Keep up the great work, enjoying the trip down memory lane. I guess I’m one of those “Friedrich detractors”. Despite some good points to his writing, I remember this period as a bit of a letdown from earlier JLA stories, even when reading them as a youngster. In particular, I distinctly recall thinking of Starbreaker as a loser, as JLA menaces go. Maybe it was partly Dillin’s design, maybe I was maturing as a reader, but I think I just never thought of him as that much of a menace, nor did I ever feel he presented a challenge to the League. Sure, he’s got this ability to absorb vast amounts of energy, he destroys planets to amp it up, but then just *sells* the energy for…what? Money? How pedestrian. No vampire certainly, but surely not nearly as frightening or “cosmic” as Galactus either, despite the similarity in powers. Maybe if he’d been skyscraper height?

    Liked by 2 people

  8. brucesfl · January 22

    Alan,

    Thanks for another enjoyable review and trip to the past. A few additional thoughts: JLA 98 would feature the last cover drawn by Neal Adams, except for 2 covers in late 1976. Nick Cardy was certainly an acceptable replacement, of course. Regarding JLA 97, I also have the Justice League Companion and there were some other interesting comments from Mike Friedrich in his interview. He mentioned that he believed strongly that heroes “do not kill” so he deliberately changed the part of the JLA origin story where it appeared that the alien had been killed. He had also intended for Starbreaker to be a new and recurring enemy for the JLA, but he was disappointed that apparently no one took him up on that in the 70s and 80s. In fact I only vaguely remember that Starbreaker was used again in the 90s. I don’t really remember what I thought of Starbreaker when I first read this 3 part story 50 years ago, but I find after reading your review I agree with the above comments that this villain is pretty generic. The resemblance to a Dracula sort of character, and that he even has fangs seems a bit unnecessary. It does seem that JLA was a difficult book to write (possibly because of having so many powerful characters), and both Denny and Mike had trouble with the book, in terms of finding the right antagonists to fight the JLA They both used many alien menaces, and Mike had noted in his interview that while Dillin was a good and competent artist, it seemed all his aliens looked the same. It’s also tough to compare JLA to Avengers since at this time Roy Thomas was at the top of his game, and it seems Roy figured out the right balance of Avengers and seemed to usually come up with interesting and varied antagonists for that team. In that same interview, Mike Friedrich mentions that the only issue of JLA that he was completely satisfied with in his run was JLA 94 which you reviewed and was a pretty good issue (and had an unexpectedly long lasting character, Merlyn). I do recall that I was starting to lose interest in JLA. I remember buying 99, but don’t remember much about it but that there was (sigh) another alien menace. But with the 100th issue I believe Len Wein understood immediately how to write this book and seemed comfortable with it from the beginning. I’ll be interested to read your comments on JLA 100 in several months.

    Liked by 2 people

    • Alan Stewart · January 22

      I’d forgotten that Friedrich specifically referenced the “heroes don’t kill” change he made to the League’s origin story in that JLC interview — guess I should have re-read the whole thing before writing this post! 🙂 Thanks for making note of it, brucesfl.

      Liked by 1 person

    • Alan Stewart · January 22

      Addendum — I’ve updated the original post with this information. Thanks again!

      Liked by 1 person

    • I did a Google search, and in a recent story Starbreaker was drawn as having a giant, glowing red energy form with much more monstrous features, which definitely gives him a more effective visual.

      Liked by 2 people

      • frednotfaith2 · January 23

        I suppose a bit like the Avengers early baddie Count Nefaria — when he finally came back for a rematch, well over 10 years after his previous appearance in the Avengers, he actually had superpowers and an appropriate update on his duds so he no longer looked like he was about to go out for a night at the opera rather than taking on a bunch of superheroes.

        Liked by 2 people

  9. Marcus · January 22

    I read this when it came out and it was the first time I saw Sargon, not having read his appearances in Flash. I also knew about Zatanna, which created a problem for me. These stories were edited by Julie Schwartz, the man behind the whole Earth I, Earth II concept, and here were characters who should have been on Earth II. Later we would also see Air Wave and the Paul Kirk Manhunter in Schwartz edited titles. For whatever reason, I didn’t have a problem with the Guardian in Jimmy Olsen, probably because that was part of Kirby’s Fourth World, which except for a few Lois Lane stories, seemed separate from the rest of the DCU at the time.

    Superman was the first superhero on Earth II, and Superboy the first on Earth I and anything else just doesn’t seem right.

    Liked by 1 person

  10. Ken Thompson · January 23

    You brought back fond memories for me with this post. I really enjoyed this three-parter and at the time, I had not read JLA #9 so I was engrossed in the plot. I think this three-parter set the table well for Len Wein’s run. A GREAT three-parter with the Justice Society, soon to be followed by a quick membership drive with the Phantom Stranger (depending on who you ask), Elongated Man and Red Tornado. The only run I enjoyed as much after this was Steve Englehart’s from 139 to 150.

    Liked by 1 person

  11. Brian Morrison · January 26

    This one was also amongst the bundle of ca 20 DC comics that I bought in March 1972 that set me on a life long path of comic collecting. Like you Alan, I thought this one was special. I had enjoyed the golden age reprints, as I have mentioned before, but I too wanted to see reprints of old JLA stories that I had missed. I had bought all the 80 and 64 page JLA giants from the previous 6 years and was eager for more. I was looking forward to a JLA 100 page Super Spectacular but alas DC would cancel these in just a few short months and I would have to wait until the middle of 1973 before DC Super Spectacular 17 hit the stands reprinting two JLA stories and a JSA story from All Star Comics featuring the first appearance of the Injustice Society of the World. I think that was the first even JSA story to be reprinted but I might be wrong in that.
    JLA 97 was my introduction to Starbreaker as I had missed issue 96. I remember thinking of him as a really serious villain because of the reaction of the JLAers at the beginning of the issue. In retrospect, I agreed with the general assessment of him when I eventually found issue 96 and read the first part of the story. That issue was also my introduction to Adam Strange, a character I had never come across before and it sent me looking for copies of the current issues of Strange Adventures where I could catch up on his early adventures.
    Alas I missed issue 98 and was only able to find it many years later when I was at university and finally read how the menace of Starbreaker was resolved.
    Like Ben Herman I didn’t find the transition between art styles to jarring, I reckon that I my 13 year old self hadn’t yet developed an eye for artistic styles. I’m in total agreement with you Alan on your assessment of Mike Friedrich’s run on JLA. I really enjoyed the way he set in place plot threads for upcoming issues and made the whole universe more connected. This was further enhanced by his use of Sargon, with his connections to the recent Flash stories and Flash’s reaction to his unexpected appearance.
    After reading this issue, I was really looking forward to seeing much more of Sargon in upcoming DC comics but also he never materialised. Checking Mike’s Amazing World, he didn’t appear again until December 1978 in Adventure Comics 462 where he was the villain in a Justice Society of America story. I liked the look and Eastern feel of Sargon with his suit, gem and turban. Only later would I find out that it was kind of generic with Yarko the Great (Fox Comics), Mr Mystic (Quality Comics) and Ibis the Invincible (Fawcett Comics) all sporting the same turban and suit look in the Golden Age.
    I didn’t mind seeing Sargon on Earth 1, I reckoned that with his magical powers, he could easily move between the two earths. After all Zatara and the Spectre, also supposedly Earth 2 residents, had both appeared on Earth 1 so I believed all magical beings could travel between earths at will.
    I did buy issue 99 but remember being disappointed by it. My hazy memory was that it had an ecological theme that I think was ahead of it’s time and didn’t resonate with me as I was living in what was at that time pollution free rural Scotland. What I do vividly remember from JLA 99 was the trail for issue 100. It promised more that 30 heroes from the JLA, JSA and a super hero group that was new to me, the Seven Soldiers of Victory. I couldn’t wait, I was so excited!

    Liked by 1 person

    • Alan Stewart · January 26

      Brian, thanks for the note on Sargon’s later appearance in Adventure #462. My original research for the post hadn’t turned up a return to villainy, so I just did a little more checking, and it seems that in that story, our turbaned friend was possessed by an evil spirit within the Ruby of Life. So, not quite a full-on heel turn — still, in the interest of accuracy, I’ve added a parenthetical “mostly” to my statement about his having stayed on the straight and narrow path after JLA #98. 😉

      Like

  12. Cornelius Featherjaw · March 3

    My father vividly remembers issue 96, mostly because he spilled stewed potatoes on it while trying to read at the dinner table.

    Liked by 2 people

  13. Pingback: Justice League of America #100 (August, 1972) | Attack of the 50 Year Old Comic Books

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.